|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
ARodomus

Posts: 45 Join date: 2009-08-27 Age: 32 Location: NYC
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Mon Sep 21, 2009 5:59 pm | |
| I've actually seen a woman getting the sh*t slapped out of her by a guy, I intervened and gently asked the guy to relax. The female then turned on me, and cursed me out for "butting in", then she told me to mind my own business. So personal experience has taught me to just keep moving. Unless it's my own, or someone I know, I generally will do as that ungrateful b*tch said, and "mind my own business". It's a sad reality. I don't often see people getting beat up, so I don't feel so bad "minding my own". As far as sounds, like Richie said, I hear it all at any given time living in a big city. I pay it no mind, I just keep moving... |
|
 | |
Russ the Muss Admin

Posts: 1560 Join date: 2008-04-17 Age: 43 Location: Washington DC
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Mon Sep 21, 2009 8:36 pm | |
| | ARodomus wrote: | | I've actually seen a woman getting the sh*t slapped out of her by a guy, I intervened and gently asked the guy to relax. The female then turned on me, and cursed me out for "butting in", then she told me to mind my own business. |
people are so screwed up...my maternal grandfather dived of a knife wound to the back--splitting up a fight, assuming the side he had chosen wouldn not cost him. however, although people are largely so fooked up, i'd leave a part of myself aside for someone asking for help mate. even if it's phoning someone on their behalf.
that particular woman...well, she can obviously go and get stuffed right? but if your mother, sister, etc... was overlooked because of such thoughts, you'd see the flaws in it right?
stand nearby, if it's no danger to you. i'd think if someone wasn't completely bat'shit'crazy they'd have a presence at some point to say, "are you going to help me?" or "help me". i say this as someone that's pretty jaded himself. it makes it harder on one's personal codes and ethics. makes things grey that really would be much better black and white. i've been in other similar situations of battered women. at some point, my help symbolically turns into them chosing me over him--if only metaphorically and not romantically. that kind of 'crazy love' usually picks the wrong man. my own sister did the same when it came to a stand off. it can make one quite jaded.
write off the individuals if you have to, but not society based on a few f&*kwits.\ _________________ Don't wait for it to happen...make it happen.
|
|
 | |
nix

Posts: 131 Join date: 2008-03-15
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Mon Sep 21, 2009 9:14 pm | |
| ARodomus; maybe talk to the victim rather than your potential target; ask her if she needs a hand; keep the target in a sight line but otherwise "appear" to be ignoring him... but it's REALLY easy quarterbacking from this armchair  |
|
 | |
ARodomus

Posts: 45 Join date: 2009-08-27 Age: 32 Location: NYC
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Mon Sep 21, 2009 10:44 pm | |
| Russ, I get it, I am not completely unwilling to help. If asked, or invited, I would not turn a blind eye. But as rule, unless I see the clear signs inviting it, I just mind my own. But I definitely get your point.
Last edited by ARodomus on Mon Sep 21, 2009 10:45 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
 | |
ARodomus

Posts: 45 Join date: 2009-08-27 Age: 32 Location: NYC
 | |
 | |
maija Admin

Posts: 609 Join date: 2008-11-08
 | |
 | |
D.M.B.

Posts: 135 Join date: 2009-04-30 Age: 30 Location: London, Ontario, Canada
 | |
 | |
RichardB

Posts: 587 Join date: 2008-02-26
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:54 am | |
| FROM THE NEWS ARTICLE | Quote: | | For several days, the community has struggled to understand how so many could stand by and watch, failing to call police or alert other adults in the area. |
What I struggle to understand is how this never fails to surprise people.
When DOES bystander intervention actually happen the way so many expect it to?
It seems to me that when it happens, the news recognize it for the rare treat it is, and present it as the sensation it is. THESE DAYS anyway...
On second thought to why people being surprised that bystanders just stand by annoys me. It's probably an instinct. But this world isn't what the instincts were attuned to. In a tribe the expectation is reasonable. Among selfish strangers in hairy situations it's not. And that seems instinctive too. Cooperation is the lifeblood of a tribe, and risking your ass over outsiders is not worth the risk. Hell I'm on a roll here... Maybe even CONDEMNING people who do not assist is instinctive. Seeing that they're bad for your tribe, and by extension; you.
From another angle there is something referred to as "the fundamental attribution error." People believe that both themselves and others are most strongly affected by their personality. In the news article video, a police officer states that these people are monsters. But the research keeps showing that what the SITUATION is has the most power to predict what will happen. Situations with many people involved snowball. Suggestible, pre-myelinated teenagers with a fucked up value system get sucked in easy.
These are fucked up people. By and large the action must have been floating fairly close to the surface in the entire group for it to have so much support, and so little resistance. It wasn't a large step for them.
They will probably get what's coming to them. Maybe not being broken on the wheel:

But the legal system is fairly good at hiding retribution and deterrence under euphemisms. So a lot of it still exists in these times of pussification. Look at the electric chair for instance. If all they wanted was to kill effectively, that's easy. Remember the video of the guy electrocuting himself on a train powerline? The second he touched it, it went KZUMM and a he turned into a blinding lightbulb for a split second. Dead and on fire, smoke rising from his smoldering hair. In the chair they take the time to cook them just right. The principle applies in many levels of the penal system. So with some help of karma, maybe the penile system will do it's job and rape them good.
Yes, that was an intentional typo.  _________________ "I have a high art, I hurt with cruelty those who would damage me." — Archirocus, 650 BC
|
|
 | |
Richard Grannon Admin

Posts: 1658 Join date: 2008-02-18 Location: UK
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:47 pm | |
| | Quote: | | When DOES bystander intervention actually happen the way so many expect it to? |
Ive not seen it myself but I believe in the east its more frequent
havent we discussed this here before somtime? _________________ “One should die proudly when it is no longer possible to live proudly.”
Nietzsche
|
|
 | |
maija Admin

Posts: 609 Join date: 2008-11-08
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:57 pm | |
| This is from the TED lecture series. Talk given by the guy who was part of the prisoners and prison guards experiment done with a group of students a while back. I think it relates here because it duscusses the group mentality, and situational behavior we are talking about. http://www.ted.com/talks/philip_zimbardo_on_the_psychology_of_evil.htmlJust watched it again ... it's about 25 mins long, but if you have the time please watch - I think this guy has some great insights. _________________ "It will be difficult at first, but then everything is difficult at first". Miyamoto Musashi
|
|
 | |
roadkill

Posts: 461 Join date: 2008-10-06 Location: US Fl. Earth
 | Subject: Re: Kitty Genovese Syndrome Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:14 pm | |
| Pretty sad reading. Can you imagine what it must be like for the parents of the victim. I honestly have no idea how I would handle such an event. I know I would lose my mind to rage for a period of time, but then what? |
|
 | |
|